Selling Your House to an Investor vs. With a New York Real Estate Agent

July 14, 2023

As a homeowner in New York, deciding whether to sell your house to an investor or work with a real estate agent can be a daunting task. To make the right decision, it is essential to understand the key differences between these two options and weigh the pros and cons of each. In this comprehensive guide, we will discuss the benefits and drawbacks of selling your house to an investor versus listing it with a real estate agent, along with helpful tips and advice on what to look for in an investor or agent and how to prepare your home for sale to maximize its value.

Investor vs. Real Estate Agent: Key Differences

Speed of Transaction


Selling your house to an investor can indeed result in a faster closing compared to traditional methods. Here are a few reasons why this option can be beneficial for homeowners:

  1. Quick Closing: Investors are often prepared to make a purchase with cash, eliminating the need for lengthy loan approval processes. As a result, they can close the deal much faster, typically within a week or two. This is advantageous for homeowners who need to sell their property quickly due to financial constraints, relocation, or other urgent reasons.
  2. As-Is Sales: Investors typically buy properties in their current condition, meaning you don’t need to invest time or money into repairs or renovations. They are accustomed to handling properties that may require repairs or updates, and they factor that into their buying decision. This saves homeowners from the hassle and expense of preparing their property for a traditional sale.
  3. Avoiding the Traditional Selling Process: Selling a house traditionally involves various steps, such as listing the property, staging, hosting showings, negotiating with buyers, and dealing with potential contingencies. By selling to an investor, homeowners can bypass these steps and simplify the selling process. This can be particularly appealing for those who prefer a more straightforward and hassle-free transaction.
  4. Certainty and Convenience: Investors are often experienced buyers who are familiar with the real estate market. They can provide a more predictable and reliable sales process, reducing the risk of deals falling through due to financing issues or buyer contingencies. Additionally, selling to an investor can offer convenience since homeowners can avoid the uncertainties associated with listing their property and waiting for a suitable buyer.

However, it’s important to note that selling to an investor might result in a lower sale price compared to selling through traditional methods. Investors typically aim to purchase properties at a discounted price to account for any repairs or updates they may need to make and to generate a profit when reselling or renting the property. It’s crucial to evaluate your priorities and circumstances before deciding on the best selling option for your specific situation.

Real Estate Agent:

When you choose to list your house with a real estate agent, the selling process typically takes longer compared to selling to an investor. Here are some reasons why it may take more time:

  1. Finding the Right Buyer: Real estate agents work to market your property, attract potential buyers, and find the most suitable match for your house. This process can involve listing the property on multiple platforms, hosting open houses, and coordinating showings. It may take some time to find a buyer who is genuinely interested and willing to make an offer.
  2. Negotiations and Contingencies: Once an offer is received, negotiations between the buyer and seller can occur. This negotiation phase can involve discussions on price, terms, and potential contingencies (such as inspections or financing). Negotiating these aspects may take time as both parties strive to reach an agreement that satisfies their respective interests.
  3. Mortgage Approval and Closing Process: After an offer is accepted, the buyer typically needs to secure financing, which involves going through the mortgage approval process. This can take several weeks as the buyer’s lender evaluates their financial information, orders an appraisal, and completes other necessary steps. Additionally, the closing process itself, which includes inspections, title searches, and document preparation, can take several weeks to complete.
  4. Potential Delays and Challenges: Various factors can cause delays during the selling process, such as difficulties in obtaining financing, appraisal issues, inspection findings, or title complications. Dealing with these challenges and resolving them can extend the time required to close the sale.

While the average home sale with an agent may take around 60-90 days to close, it’s essential to note that the timeline can vary depending on market conditions, location, property type, and other factors. Additionally, some properties may sell more quickly, while others may take longer to find the right buyer.

Working with a real estate agent offers the advantage of their expertise in marketing, negotiating, and navigating the selling process. They can guide you through each step and help you maximize your chances of selling at a favorable price. However, if you’re in a hurry to sell or prefer a quicker and more streamlined process, selling to an investor may be a more suitable option.



Selling your house to an investor can often involve fewer upfront costs compared to selling through traditional methods. Here are some reasons why:

  1. “As-Is” Sales: Investors typically purchase properties in their current condition. This means you don’t have to invest time or money into repairs, renovations, or staging before selling. Investors are accustomed to buying properties that may need some work, and they factor that into their buying decision. By selling “as-is,” you can save on the costs and efforts associated with preparing your property for a traditional sale.
  2. Avoiding Repairs and Improvements: When selling to an investor, you can skip the need to make any repairs or improvements to your house. Traditional buyers often expect properties to be in good condition, and they may negotiate repairs or ask for concessions. Investors, on the other hand, are typically willing to take on properties in any condition, allowing you to avoid the costs and hassle of fixing up your home.
  3. No Commissions: In a traditional real estate transaction, you usually need to pay a commission to the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. However, when you sell directly to an investor, you can bypass the need for real estate agents altogether, potentially eliminating the commission fees associated with their services. This can save you a significant amount of money, as commissions typically range from 5% to 6% of the sale price.
  4. Limited Closing Costs: If the investor is paying cash for your property, you can often avoid some of the typical closing costs associated with mortgage financing, such as loan origination fees or appraisal fees. Cash buyers often simplify the closing process and minimize expenses related to loan processing.

It’s important to note that while selling to an investor can save you money on upfront costs, the trade-off may be accepting a lower sale price for your property. Investors typically aim to purchase properties at a discount to account for any repairs or updates they may need to make and to generate a profit when reselling or renting the property. Before deciding to sell to an investor, carefully consider your financial goals and priorities to ensure it aligns with your overall objectives.

Real Estate Agent:

When selling a house through a traditional real estate agent, there are various costs and fees involved, including repairs, staging, and commissions. Here’s a breakdown of these potential expenses:

  1. Repairs and Improvements: To attract potential buyers and fetch a higher sale price, it’s common for sellers working with agents to invest in repairs and improvements. This may include fixing any issues with the property, such as plumbing, electrical, or structural problems, as well as cosmetic upgrades like painting, flooring, or landscaping. These expenses can add up depending on the condition of your home and the extent of repairs or improvements needed.
  2. Staging: Staging involves arranging furniture, decor, and accessories in a way that enhances the appeal of your home to potential buyers. Professional stagers may be hired to create an inviting atmosphere that showcases the property’s potential. Staging costs can vary depending on the size of your home and the duration of the staging period.
  3. Commissions: When you work with a real estate agent, you typically pay a commission based on a percentage of the final sale price. The standard commission rate is around 5-6% of the sale price, although this can vary. The commission is usually split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent involved in the transaction. It’s important to consider this cost when calculating your potential net proceeds from the sale.
  4. Other Closing Costs: In addition to commissions, there are other closing costs involved in a traditional sale, such as title insurance, escrow fees, attorney fees, and transfer taxes. These costs can vary depending on the location and specific circumstances of the sale.

It’s worth noting that while these expenses can add up, working with a real estate agent can offer advantages such as their expertise in marketing, negotiating, and navigating the selling process. They can help you attract potential buyers, negotiate offers, and handle the paperwork and legal aspects of the transaction.

Ultimately, the decision between working with an agent or selling to an investor depends on your specific needs, timeline, financial situation, and priorities. It’s advisable to carefully evaluate the potential costs and benefits of each option before making a decision.

Ease of Process


Indeed, selling your home to an investor can often involve a more straightforward process with less paperwork compared to traditional methods. Here are some reasons why selling to an investor can be quicker and simpler:

  1. Streamlined Process: Investors are typically experienced in purchasing properties, and they often have well-defined processes in place. They are accustomed to handling the necessary paperwork efficiently, which can help streamline the transaction. Since they are buying the property directly from you, there may be fewer parties involved, reducing the complexity of the process.
  2. Fewer Contingencies: When selling to an investor, the sale is often not contingent on factors like financing or the sale of another property. Investors often have the funds readily available to make a cash purchase, eliminating the need for financing contingencies. This can significantly simplify the transaction and reduce the potential for delays or complications.
  3. Closing Cost Coverage: Depending on the terms of the sale, investors may be willing to cover some or all of the closing costs. This can include expenses such as title search fees, escrow fees, or attorney fees. By taking care of these costs, investors can alleviate the financial burden on the seller and make the selling process more convenient.
  4. Limited Legal Matters: Investors are typically well-versed in real estate transactions and have the resources to handle legal matters efficiently. They often have a team of professionals, such as attorneys or title companies, who can navigate the legal requirements associated with the sale. This can simplify the process for the seller and ensure that all necessary documentation is handled properly.

While selling to an investor can offer a quicker and simpler experience, it’s important to note that it’s still crucial to review any contracts or agreements thoroughly and seek legal advice if necessary. While investors can provide a smoother process, it’s essential to protect your interests and ensure that the terms of the sale align with your needs and expectations.

As with any significant financial transaction, it’s advisable to research potential investors, understand their reputation, and consider multiple offers to make an informed decision.

Real Estate Agent:

Absolutely, selling a house with a real estate agent can involve a more complex process compared to selling to an investor. Here are some aspects that contribute to the complexity when working with an agent:

  1. Finding Suitable Buyers: Real estate agents are responsible for marketing your property and finding potential buyers who are genuinely interested and qualified. This can involve listing your property on multiple platforms, conducting open houses, and coordinating showings. The agent needs to attract suitable buyers who meet your requirements and are willing to make an offer.
  2. Negotiating on Your Behalf: Once offers are received, the agent acts as your representative during the negotiation process. They aim to secure the best possible price and terms on your behalf. Negotiations can involve multiple counteroffers, considerations of contingencies, and other aspects that require careful communication and negotiation skills. The agent’s role is to advocate for your interests throughout this process.
  3. Paperwork and Documentation: Selling a house involves various legal and administrative documents. Real estate agents handle the paperwork related to the transaction, including sales contracts, disclosure forms, title documentation, and more. Ensuring the accuracy and completeness of these documents is crucial to a successful sale. Agents are trained and experienced in navigating the paperwork requirements to ensure compliance and protect your interests.
  4. Dealing with Contingencies: Real estate transactions often involve contingencies, which are conditions that must be met for the sale to proceed. Common contingencies include financing, inspections, and appraisal. The agent guides you through managing these contingencies, coordinating necessary inspections, negotiating repairs, and working with the buyer to meet the requirements within the specified timeline.
  5. Time and Attention Required: Selling a house through an agent can require significant time and attention from the seller. You may need to be available for showings, respond to inquiries, and provide necessary information or documentation requested by the agent. Coordinating with the agent and potential buyers throughout the process can be time-consuming.

While working with a real estate agent can involve a more complex process, their expertise, market knowledge, and negotiation skills can be invaluable in achieving a successful sale. They handle the intricacies of the transaction, guide you through the steps, and work towards securing the best possible outcome.

Tips for Choosing an Investor or Real Estate Agent


  1. Look for a reputable and experienced investor who specializes in buying properties in your area.
  2. Check their past transaction history and ask for references.
  3. Ensure the investor provides clear and transparent communication about the purchase process.

Real Estate Agent

  1. Choose an agent with a strong track record of selling properties similar to yours in the local market.
  2. Look for someone who has a robust marketing plan and utilizes multiple channels for exposure.
  3. Select an agent who is proactive and communicates effectively.

In conclusion, when deciding between selling your house to an investor like DealHouse or working with a New York real estate agent, DealHouse emerges as the preferred option. With a streamlined and expedited process, the ability to buy houses in their current condition, and the elimination of costly commissions and fees, DealHouse offers convenience, efficiency, and cost-effectiveness. Their flexibility in closing dates and commitment to customer satisfaction further solidify their position as a reputable choice for homeowners. By choosing DealHouse, you can confidently sell your house and transition to the next phase of your life with peace of mind.


Chris Chiarenza